Jump to content

TIKI-TAKA

Bringing you the beautiful game


Rank Them

This topic has been archived. This means that you cannot reply to this topic.
4 replies to this topic

#1   Roger

Roger

Posted 15 August 2012 - 09:32 PM

So this is a rather simple exercise:

1. Rank our players based on their value to the club.

2. Rank our players based on your like/dislike of the player.


--------------------------------------------------------------

Player List (official list of first team players):

1 - Valdes
2 - Alves
3 - Pique
4 - Cesc
5 - Puyol
6 - Xavi
7 - Villa
8 - Iniesta
9 - Alexis
10 - Messi
11 - Thiago
12 - Dos Santos
13 - Pinto
14 - Mascherano
15 - Bartra
16 - Busquets
17 - Pedro
18 - Alba
19 - Montoya
20 - Afellay
21 - Adriano
22 - Abidal
23 - Cuenca
24 - Fontas

-------------------------------------------

My Value Rank (keep in mind this is based on current abilities and age, but not health... I assume the player is fit to play for this ranking):

1. Messi
2. Busquets
3. Puyol
4. Xavi
5. Iniesta
6. Valdes
7. Pique
8. Alves
9. Abidal
10. Alexis
11. Villa
12. Mascherano
13. Cesc
14. Alba
15. Pedro
16. Thiago
17. Cuenca
18. Adriano
19. Pinto
20. Dos Santos
21. Bartra
22. Afellay
23. Montoya
24. Fontas



My Like/Dislike Rank:

1. Messi
2. Abidal
3. Puyol
4. Mascherano
5. Pique
6. Iniesta
7. Xavi
8. Cuenca
9. Busquets
10. Thiago
11. Villa
12. Valdes
13. Adriano
14. Alexis
15. Pedro
16. Cesc
17. Alba
18. Alves
19. Pinto
20. Montoya
21. Bartra
22. Afellay
23. Dos Santos
24. Fontas

Roger

Posted Image


#2   Capita

Capita
  • Active Member
  • posts: 1,631
  • Fav PlayersLeo Messi and Andres Iniesta
  • SupportsFC Barcelona

Posted 15 August 2012 - 11:36 PM

Value:

1. Messi
2. Xavi
3. Iniesta
4. Puyol
5. Alves
6. Busquets
7. Valdes
8. Piqué
9. Villa
10. Alexis
11. Mascherano
12. Pedro
13. Alba
14. Adriano
15. Cesc
16. Thiago
17. Pinto
18. Adriano
19. Montoya
20. Afellay
21. Bartra
22. Dos Santos
23. Fontas
24. Abidal (just reflecting current utility to the team)

Like/Dislike

1. Iniesta
2. Abidal
3. Pique
4. Alves
5. Messi
6. Puyol
7. Villa
8. Xavi
9. Cesc
10. Alexis
11. Mascherano
12. Thiago
13. Pedro
14. Afellay
15. Busquets
16. Valdes
17. Pinto
18. Montoya
19. Alba
20. Adriano
21. Bartra
22. Cuenca
23. Dos Santos
24. Fontas

Edited by 0, 15 August 2012 - 11:38 PM.

Capità


Posted Image


#3   Zin

Zin
  • Spain Moderators
  • posts: 7,026
  • LocationMississippi
  • Fav PlayersAbidal, Messi, Iniesta, Xavi, Pique, Neymar
  • SupportsFC Barcelona

Posted 16 August 2012 - 12:05 AM

Value:

1. Messi
2. Iniesta
3. Busquets
4. Xavi
5. Puyol
6. Pique
7. Mascherano
8. Villa
9. Alexis
10. Valdes
11. Cesc
12. Thiago
13. Pinto (incredible locker room presence)
14. Alves (Montoya lessens his value for me)
15. Alba
16. Montoya
17. Pedro
18. Afellay
19. Adriano
20. dos Santos
21. Cuenca
22. Bartra
23. Fontas
24. Abidal

___________________________________________________

Like/dislike:


1. Messi
2. Iniesta
3. Pique
4. Abidal
5. Puyol
6. Xavi
7. Thiago
8. Alexis
9. Mascherano
10. Villa
11. Alves
12. Pinto
13. Afellay
14. Montoya
15. Cesc
16. Pedro
17. Busquets
18. Valdes
19. Alba (unknown entity)
20. Cuenca
21. dos Santos
22. Adriano
23. Bartra
24. Fontas

!!!! I AM TOTALLY KEVIN !!!!

And who are you , the proud lord said, that I must bow so low?
Tiki-Taka Best Moderator of 2012
Tiki-Taka Best Thread "At the Bar" of 2012


#4   Roberto Rivelino

Roberto Rivelino
  • Portugal Moderators
  • posts: 6,403
  • LocationPortugal.
  • Fav PlayersDonovan, Hugo Viana, Plasil, Huth, Pavlyuchenko
  • SupportsJuventus, Porto and any Joga Bonito Team

Posted 17 August 2012 - 01:00 AM

Value:

1. Busquets
2. Messi
3. Iniesta
4. Xavi
5. Puyol
6. Mascherano
7. Alves
8. Valdes
9. Pique
10. Cesc
11. Villa
12. Thiago
13. Pinto
14. Alexis Sanchez
15. Adriano
16. Montoya
17. Pedro
18. Afellay
19. Cuenca
20. dos Santos
21. Fontas
22. Bartra
23. Alba (hasn't made anything yet)
24. Abidal (due to his problems, can't rate him)

___________________________________________________

Like/dislike:

1. Mascherano
2. Afellay
3. Adriano
4. Abidal
5. Puyol
6. Xavi
7. Alves
8. Messi
9. Iniesta
10. Villa
11. Thiago
12. Pinto
13. Pique
14. Montoya
15. Cesc
16. Pedro
17. Busquets
18. Valdes
19. Alba
20. Cuenca
21. dos Santos
22. Alexis
23. Bartra
24. Fontas

@Zin Kind off took some numbers as they do apply to my "situation".


All my Video Match Compilations were taken from Youtube, therefore, they'll be (all) updated on my blog.
Follow me if you please on Roberto Rivelino. Thanks.


#5   Squibo

Squibo

Posted 18 August 2012 - 06:27 PM

Value

1. Messi - Should be obvious, goals, assists, whatever
2. Iniesta - His winning record says a lot about his value
3. Busquets - Future captain. His passing game allows makes us better
4. Xavi - Dat vision
5. Mascherano - our #1 defender now IMO.. would be worried if he went down with a long term injury
6. Puyol - Captain. Heart and soul of the team. We're better with him though see Masherano
7. Villa - His injury was the biggest reason to why we failed to win a major trophy IMO
8. Alves - What other RB plays more in the forward half than Dani?
9. Valdes - Well, without him it's that ponytailed guy. Would be considerably higher if it wasn't for Pinto's improvement of the past 12 months
10. Piqué - Needs to spend more time focussed on finding his 10/11 form and less time with Shakira
11. Alexis - Hard one to judge but has looked very good in pre season
12. Cesc - Second season should be interesting. Super versatile
13. Pedro - Pressure pressure pressure. Still offers loads of it
14. Pinto - Need a rule that he comes on every time we're faced against a penalty. Boss
15. Thiago - Starting to feature more predominantly. Will feature highly on such a list in several years
16. Adriano - Better crosser of the ball than Dani. Way too injury prone
17. Cuenca - Our only real winger. Very handy last season
18. Afellay - What is his role? Beats me. Is good but has struggled
19. Bartra - Next generations captain (whenever that is, 10 years?)
20. Montoya - Promising player who has often slotted in very comfortably. Should get more minutes this season.
21. Dos Santos - Stuck in the situation of been probably too good for the B team but not good enough to really crack the first team
22. Fontas - Never really convinced me.. injuries haven't helped his cause however.

Left our Alba and Abidal and I suppose now Song. Alba looked alright in his pre season games though hard to an accurate judgment just yet. Abidal due to his unknown future. Would be around 8th otherwise. Song.. time will tell.

Like

1. Messi
2. Iniesta
3. Puyol
4. Xavi
5. Villa
6. Busquets
7. Abidal
8. Piqué
9. Mascherano
10. Alexis
11. Valdes
12. Pedro
13. Pinto
14. Cesc
15. Dani
16. Thiago
17. Alba
18. Bartra
19. Afellay
20. Adriano
21. Cuenca
22. Montoya
23. Dos Santos
24. Fontas

Cesc and Dani much lower as I find them to be incredibly frustrating players to watch at times. Song the unknown here.

Posted Image

FC Barcelona Official Competitive Goals

Lionel Messi - 315